| 
4 February 2002
Anne Spiselman
Crain's Chicago Business
Keefer's is designed with the business diner in mind.
Of the new downtown restaurants, this collaboration of brothers
Glenn and Richard Keefer, radio industry mogul Jimmy de Castro and
executive chef John Hogan distinguishes itself by serving appealing
but not-too-challenging steaks and seafood in a contemporary, conversation-conducive
setting.
Floor-to-ceiling windows and a 50-foot-long crescent-shaped bar
with bottle-filled shelves curving around part of the circular main
dining area are among the dramatic features, as is a lobster tank
built into a stone wall. Booths and white-clothed tables surrounded
by handsome wood chairs fill this and two smaller rooms decorated
with vintage radios, black-and-white photos of broadcast personalities
and colorful posters that pay homage to Mr. de Castro's career.
The menu reflects Glenn Keefer's management experience with the
Ruth's Chris Steak House chain and chef Hogan's cooking at his dearly
departed French bistro, Savarin, as well as at Kiki's Bistro and
Park Avenue Cafe. Lunch entrees include a cup of soup or a small
house or Caesar salad, but you also can order from the dinner lineup.
Meals get off to a good start with several kinds of bread, sweet
butter and a little dish of olives and pickled vegetables. Best
of the cold openers is the pair of pates, a country-style duck pate
with pistachios and a creamy, deeply flavorful chicken liver pate,
with appropriate garnishes and toasted baguettes. Smoked salmon
on potatoes rostii doesn't quite work: The disk of crunchy deep-fried
potato threads is reminiscent of shredded wheat and overwhelms the
buttery salmon painted with horseradish sauce.
Of the hot appetizers, beef tenderloin "Dianne" easily
can double as a light entree. Three medallions of extremely tender,
cooked-as-ordered meat bask with mushrooms and shallots in a rich
sauce enhanced by red wine and Cognac.
Hearty split-pea soup with smoked ham and sausage-improved by sprinkles
of salt and pepper-is one day's special. Lobster bisque and chicken
noodle soup are always on hand.
Despite pre-grated Parmesan, the Caesar salad surpasses the mixed
greens, thanks to the delicious, assertive dressing. A large Caesar
is available as a main course with filet mignon, shrimp or smoked
chicken breast. The ... la carte "country salad" is a
classic salade lyonnaise by another name: frisee, bacon and croutons
crowned by a poached egg-and, in this case, marred by a mouth-puckeringly
tart sherry-walnut vinaigrette.
Steaks loom large among the entrees, but my lunch ribeye-Delmonico
is a bit of a disappointment. Billed as "USDA Prime,"
the inch-thick boneless slab rimmed with fat is rare, as ordered,
but the reasonably tasty meat is so heavily salted, it's almost
inedible.
Sauteed fluke, on the other hand, sparkles. Coated with browned
breadcrumbs, the fillet is beautifully moist in the center, cannily
mated with wild mushrooms and set off by bright-green watercress
sauce. A choice of potatoes-lumpy whipped, fries or a little croquette
stuffed with bacon, chives and cheese (and still cold inside)-accompanies
both.
Pan-roasted salmon and fish and chips are other seafood entrees,
as is a pot pie that brings together succulent sea scallops, lobster
morsels, shelled mussels and other goodies under an impressive puff
of golden-brown pastry. The remainder of the possibilities range
from eggs Florentine to spinach and roasted-tomato ravioli, an ill-conceived
marriage of doughy pasta pillows and cold arugula-diced mozzarella
salad.
A whole poached pear in an almond-encrusted cookie cup glazed with
caramel sauce is a lovely, comparatively light dessert. The most
decadent is "triple chocolate," meltingly fudgy flourless
cake with a scoop of bittersweet chocolate-honey ice cream draped
with chocolate sauce.
Interesting wines by the glass (or bottle), amenities such as a
stick of rock sugar with the espresso and generally professional
service round out lunches that should encourage repeat customers.
Crain's Chicago Business uses a four-fork system of rating restaurants,
with the following values: one fork-above average; two forks-very
good; three forks-excellent; four forks-world-class. In addition,
there are "satisfactory" and "unsatisfactory"
categories, which rank below one fork.
Keefer's
20 W. Kinzie St. (312) 467-9525
Open: Lunch and dinner Mon.-Sat.
Lunch entrees: $11-$23 (on the lunch menu)
Rating: 1 1/2
Food quality: Complicated seafood dishes sometimes outshine simple
steaks
Ambiance: Handsome, good lighting, well-spaced tables (best are
booths by the windows), not too noisy; excellent for business lunches
Tidbits: Valet parking ($9); wheelchair-accessible; non-smoking
section; private dining available; reservations taken
Return to Main Reviews Menu
|